The State of Artificial Intelligence: A Discussion on Human-Level Intelligence

The discussion on artificial intelligence (AI) is a complex and multifaceted one, with many questions surrounding what it means to be intelligent and how we measure the intelligence of an artificial machine. The speaker of this video begins by questioning their own understanding of intelligence, stating that they don't know what intelligence means and are unsure about how to define it. This lack of clarity on the definition of intelligence highlights the need for a thorough exploration of the concept.

The foundations of our discussion appear to be centered around human-level or superhuman intelligence. The speaker asks whether there is a good test for measuring the intelligence of an artificial machine, suggesting that natural language conversation could be a viable option. They express their willingness to engage in conversations with a chatbot, implying that they would find it impressive if the chatbot could have a personality and pass the Turing test. However, they also raise concerns about the potential consequences of creating machines that are indistinguishable from humans, highlighting the need for careful consideration when developing AI.

The speaker's thoughts on the subject are further illuminated by their discussion of anthropomorphism - the attribution of human characteristics to non-human entities, such as robots. They suggest that if a robot were to exhibit behaviors that simulate pain or suffering, it would be easy to anthropomorphize and consider it "human." This raises important questions about the boundaries between human and machine intelligence and the potential consequences of blurring these lines.

The speaker's discussion also touches on the concept of qualia - the subjective experience of sensations such as pain or pleasure. They acknowledge that if a robot were capable of experiencing qualia, it would be essential to treat it with caution and avoid causing it harm, even if it is simply a machine. This highlights the need for empathy and understanding when developing AI, particularly in situations where machines are designed to interact with humans.

The speaker's conversation also raises questions about the potential applications of AI, including its use in tasks such as content recommendation on social media platforms like Facebook and YouTube. These platforms rely on complex algorithms that can manipulate user behavior, raising concerns about the ethics of AI development and deployment.

In conclusion, the discussion on artificial intelligence highlights the complexities and challenges associated with creating machines that are intelligent enough to be considered human-like. The speaker's thoughts on anthropomorphism, qualia, and the potential consequences of developing AI serve as a reminder of the need for careful consideration and responsible development of these technologies.

"WEBVTTKind: captionsLanguage: enlet's jump back to it artificial intelligence what's your thought of the state of where we are at currently with artificial intelligence and what do you think it takes to build human level or superhuman level intelligence I don't know what intelligence means that's my biggest question at the moment and it's I think it's cuz my instinct is always to go well what are the foundations here of our discussion what does it mean to be intelligent how do we measure the intelligence of an artificial machine or a program or something can we say that humans are intelligent because there's also a fascinating field of how do you measure human intelligence of course but if we just take that for granted saying that to whatever this fuzzy intelligence thing we're talking about humans kind of have it what would be a good test for you so during develop a test that's natural language conversation would that impress you a chatbot that you'd want to hang out and have a beer with of you know for a bunch of hours or have dinner plans with with is that a good test natural energy conversation is there something else that would impress you or is that also to differ yeah I'm pretty much impressed by everything well I think if Roomba if there was a chatbot that was like incredibly and I don't know really had a personality and I if I didn't be the the Turing test right like if I'm unable to tell that it's not another person but then I was shown a bunch of wires and mechanical components and it was like that's actually what's you're talking to I don't know if I would feel that guilty destroying it I would feel guilty because clearly it's well made and it's a really cool thing it's like destroying a really cool car or something but I would not feel like I was a murderer so yeah at what point when I start to feel that way and and this is such a subjective psychological question if you give it movement or if you have it mmm act as though or perhaps really feel pain as I destroy it and scream and resist then I'd feel that yeah that's beautifully put and less say act like it's a pain so if you just have a robot that not screams just like moans in pain if you kick it yeah that immediately just puts it in a class that we humans it becomes it we anthropomorphize it it almost be immediately it becomes human yeah that's technology question as opposed to sort of a physics question right I think that's a really good instinct to have you know if the robot screams screams and and and moans even if you don't believe that it has the mental experience the qualia of pain and suffering I think it's still a good instinct to say you know what I'd rather not hurt it the problem is that instant can get us in trouble because then robots can manipulate that and you know there's different kinds of robots as robots like the Facebook and the YouTube algorithm that recommends the video and they can manipulate in the same kind of way youlet's jump back to it artificial intelligence what's your thought of the state of where we are at currently with artificial intelligence and what do you think it takes to build human level or superhuman level intelligence I don't know what intelligence means that's my biggest question at the moment and it's I think it's cuz my instinct is always to go well what are the foundations here of our discussion what does it mean to be intelligent how do we measure the intelligence of an artificial machine or a program or something can we say that humans are intelligent because there's also a fascinating field of how do you measure human intelligence of course but if we just take that for granted saying that to whatever this fuzzy intelligence thing we're talking about humans kind of have it what would be a good test for you so during develop a test that's natural language conversation would that impress you a chatbot that you'd want to hang out and have a beer with of you know for a bunch of hours or have dinner plans with with is that a good test natural energy conversation is there something else that would impress you or is that also to differ yeah I'm pretty much impressed by everything well I think if Roomba if there was a chatbot that was like incredibly and I don't know really had a personality and I if I didn't be the the Turing test right like if I'm unable to tell that it's not another person but then I was shown a bunch of wires and mechanical components and it was like that's actually what's you're talking to I don't know if I would feel that guilty destroying it I would feel guilty because clearly it's well made and it's a really cool thing it's like destroying a really cool car or something but I would not feel like I was a murderer so yeah at what point when I start to feel that way and and this is such a subjective psychological question if you give it movement or if you have it mmm act as though or perhaps really feel pain as I destroy it and scream and resist then I'd feel that yeah that's beautifully put and less say act like it's a pain so if you just have a robot that not screams just like moans in pain if you kick it yeah that immediately just puts it in a class that we humans it becomes it we anthropomorphize it it almost be immediately it becomes human yeah that's technology question as opposed to sort of a physics question right I think that's a really good instinct to have you know if the robot screams screams and and and moans even if you don't believe that it has the mental experience the qualia of pain and suffering I think it's still a good instinct to say you know what I'd rather not hurt it the problem is that instant can get us in trouble because then robots can manipulate that and you know there's different kinds of robots as robots like the Facebook and the YouTube algorithm that recommends the video and they can manipulate in the same kind of way you\n"