**Single Stick Test: Corsair's Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 Card**
In this test, I ran CrystalDiskMark on Corsair's Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card to assess its performance. The random write 4K QD 32 results show a moderate level of performance, with the device completing the test in a reasonable time. However, the read and QDF1 tests reveal more interest. The random reads and writes are pretty uninteresting, but looking down to the higher speed transfer options like Random Read 5.12 K, we see that there's actually a big difference between the Innotech device and the onboard USB 3.0 ports.
The sequential reads show a significant performance drop, with almost an 80MB/s loss in speed due to saturation. However, the sequential writes perform just fine, indicating that the device can handle high-speed transfers without any major issues. These results suggest that while the Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card performs well in most tests, it may struggle with extremely high-speed data transfer when all ports are saturated.
**Dual Stick Test: Innotech PCIE Card**
Moving on to the dual stick test, we finally get some more interesting numbers. The random reads and writes are relatively uninteresting, but looking at the higher speed transfer options like Random Read 5.12 K, we see a significant difference between the Innotech device and the onboard USB 3.0 ports. Specifically, the Innotech card outperforms the onboard controller by almost 40MB/s in random read speeds.
This performance gap highlights the importance of having a high-quality controller when it comes to USB 3.0 devices. In this case, the Innotech PCIE card is able to handle higher speeds and saturation better than the onboard USB 3.0 ports on the motherboard. This means that if you're planning to use multiple devices at once and need high-speed transfers, a card like the Innotech PCIE would be a good choice.
**Comparison with Corsair's Voyager**
In contrast to the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card, which performed well but not spectacularly in our single stick test, the Innotech device outperforms it in several key areas. The performance gap between the two devices is significant, particularly in high-speed transfer scenarios.
The question remains whether this difference is worth paying for. If you're looking for a reliable USB 3.0 card that can handle multiple devices and high-speed transfers without issue, then the Innotech device may be a good choice. However, if you're on a budget or don't plan to push your devices to their limits, the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card is still an excellent option.
**Budget Considerations**
The price of both cards plays a significant role in determining which one is the better value. The Innotech PCIE card costs around $20-$30, while the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card costs significantly more, at around $50-$60. Considering the performance difference between the two devices, it's clear that the Innotech card offers a better bang for your buck.
In terms of budget, there are also some considerations to keep in mind when choosing a USB 3.0 device. If you're planning to use high-speed transfers frequently, then investing in a higher-end controller or card may be necessary. In this case, the additional cost is likely worth it, as it will ensure that your devices can handle high-speed transfers without issue.
**Conclusion**
In conclusion, both the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card and the Innotech PCIE card offer impressive performance in their respective tests. However, the results also highlight some key differences between the two devices. The Innotech device outperforms the Corsair Voyager in several areas, particularly in high-speed transfer scenarios.
Ultimately, the choice between these two cards will depend on your specific needs and budget. If you're looking for a reliable USB 3.0 card that can handle multiple devices and high-speed transfers without issue, then the Innotech PCIE card is an excellent option. However, if you're on a tighter budget or don't plan to push your devices to their limits, the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card is still a great choice.
**Recommendation**
Based on our testing and analysis, we recommend the Innotech PCIE card for users who:
* Plan to use high-speed transfers frequently
* Need a reliable controller for multiple devices
* Are willing to invest in a higher-end device
On the other hand, we recommend the Corsair Voyager 32GB USB 3.0 card for users who:
* Are on a tighter budget
* Don't plan to push their devices to their limits
* Just need a reliable USB 3.0 card for general use