The Flawed Windows 10 Update Process: A Critique of Microsoft's Approach

A recent update to Windows 10 has brought with it several bugs, including file deletion issues. These bugs are not only frustrating for users but also raise serious concerns about the reliability and stability of the operating system. In this article, we will examine the flaws in Microsoft's approach to updating Windows 10 and why these issues need to be addressed.

One of the main problems with the current update process is that it does not prompt users to overwrite files, which can lead to file deletion bugs. This means that even if a user has no intention of deleting any files, the update may still overwrite them anyway. The lack of notification or confirmation about this potential risk makes the whole experience feel arbitrary and frustrating for users.

Another issue with the current update process is that it relies heavily on user feedback to identify bugs. Microsoft's Insider Feedback Hub is meant to provide a way for users to report issues with updates, but it has been criticized for being flawed. The system is based on user ratings, which can lead to biased reporting of issues. Furthermore, even if a user reports an issue, it may not be taken seriously by Microsoft unless it receives a high rating from other users. This means that legitimate issues like file deletion bugs may go unreported or undiagnosed.

The problem with relying on user feedback is that it assumes that every user will report their issues in the same way and at the same time. However, this is not the case. Many users do not report issues immediately, especially if they are not critical to the functionality of the operating system. This means that some bugs may go undetected for months or even years after the update is released.

Furthermore, Microsoft's approach to testing updates is also flawed. By relying on user feedback and not doing enough in-house testing, Microsoft misses out on opportunities to catch bugs before they reach users. This is especially true for critical systems like legacy computers, which may be unable to handle the stress of a failed update.

The impact of this lack of attention to detail can be devastating. Users who rely on their computers for work or other critical tasks may find themselves facing blue screens, constant crashes, and even complete system failures. This is unacceptable and highlights the need for Microsoft to do more to test its updates before releasing them to users.

One potential solution to this problem is for users to delay updates whenever possible. If a user has no urgent need to install an update, they can simply defer it until later. This may seem like a small change, but it can make a big difference in the reliability of the operating system. By giving users more control over when they install updates, Microsoft can reduce the risk of bugs and ensure that its operating system is stable and secure.

Another solution is for users to seek out alternative solutions. For many users, this means switching to a different operating system like Linux. While it may not be practical for all users, especially those who rely on their computers for work or other critical tasks, it can be a viable option for those who are willing to make the switch.

In conclusion, Microsoft's approach to updating Windows 10 is flawed and needs to be improved. By relying too heavily on user feedback and not doing enough in-house testing, Microsoft misses out on opportunities to catch bugs before they reach users. This can have devastating consequences for users who rely on their computers for work or other critical tasks. To address this issue, Microsoft needs to take a more proactive approach to testing its updates and giving users more control over when they install them.

A New Approach is Needed

Microsoft's latest update to Windows 10 has brought with it several bugs, including file deletion issues. These bugs are not only frustrating for users but also raise serious concerns about the reliability and stability of the operating system. In this article, we will examine a new approach that Microsoft can take to improve the update process.

One potential solution is for Microsoft to revamp its Insider Feedback Hub. While the current system has been criticized for being flawed, it is still a good starting point. However, by making some changes, Microsoft can make the system more effective at identifying bugs and providing users with useful feedback. For example, Microsoft could add more features to allow users to provide detailed information about their issue, such as screenshots and error logs.

Another potential solution is for Microsoft to do more in-house testing of its updates. By testing updates on a wider range of systems and devices, Microsoft can catch bugs before they reach users. This will require significant investments in resources and personnel, but it will be worth it in the end.

Additionally, Microsoft needs to give users more control over when they install updates. By allowing users to delay or cancel updates at any time, Microsoft can reduce the risk of bugs and ensure that its operating system is stable and secure.

Legacy Computers are at Risk

One group of users who are particularly vulnerable to these bugs are legacy computer owners. These computers were designed and built before Windows 10 was released, and they do not have the same level of testing and validation as newer systems.

For this reason, legacy computer owners need to be especially careful when it comes to updating their operating system. By installing updates without proper testing and validation, Microsoft can cause irreparable damage to these computers. This is why it is essential for legacy computer owners to delay or cancel updates whenever possible.

The Impact of Bugs on Legacy Computers

The impact of bugs on legacy computers can be devastating. These computers may not have the same level of hardware or software resources as newer systems, making them more vulnerable to crashes and failures. When a bug occurs, it can cause the computer to freeze or crash, losing all unsaved work and data.

In some cases, bugs can even cause permanent damage to the system. For example, if a user tries to update their operating system without proper testing and validation, they may end up with a corrupted system that cannot be fixed. This is why it is essential for legacy computer owners to exercise extreme caution when it comes to updating their operating system.

Conclusion

The flaws in Microsoft's approach to updating Windows 10 are clear. By relying too heavily on user feedback and not doing enough in-house testing, Microsoft misses out on opportunities to catch bugs before they reach users. This can have devastating consequences for users who rely on their computers for work or other critical tasks.

To address this issue, Microsoft needs to take a more proactive approach to testing its updates and giving users more control over when they install them. By revamping its Insider Feedback Hub, doing more in-house testing, and allowing users to delay or cancel updates at any time, Microsoft can reduce the risk of bugs and ensure that its operating system is stable and secure.

For legacy computer owners, this means exercising extreme caution when it comes to updating their operating system. By delaying or canceling updates whenever possible, these users can minimize the risk of damage to their computers.

"WEBVTTKind: captionsLanguage: enall right I'm actually in the middle of recording a PC a really cool PC build project for my wife but we've got some more Windows 10 news that I'm not actually all that excited to share with you today and this camera was set up to do b-roll for the PC build so hopefully settings are right this is with my new Ursa mini pro 4.6 Kay have been working on loud learning rather so Jason Eve Angelo I hope that's how you say his name is a tech writer over at Forbes who I've been following and interacting a lot with with regards to Linux stuff and so naturally it comes up that there has been yet another file deletion bug discovered within the Windows 10 18:09 update now keep in mind 18:09 has apparently not actually started rolling back out to users yet and if you missed all of my videos there it rolled out and then there was an issue with it where it was deleting user library folders if you had moved them to another directory and left files in the previous one I outlined all of the issues that may have resulted in that affecting you in a previous video I'll have that linked in the description or the YouTube card icon or whatever and I was affected myself I had about three or four machines that all auto update it even though these are only supposed to be rolling out to insiders and those who manually chose the update I had a few rigs that auto updated and my grandmother's machine auto updated she didn't lose any files but her Microsoft Word installation and her printer drivers got totally borked like I was able eventually after like an hour fix her printer but her Microsoft Word installation is just all kinds of screwed but it was affecting a lot of people and while a lot of people thought I was just being a conspiracy theorist there were a lot of people also in the comments echoing that it was affecting them as well well while insiders were more thoroughly testing the 18:09 bug or 18:09 update same thing I guess as it's supposed to be fixed now and rolling back out they have discovered another file deletion bug that results from their file extracting during the update process we're extracting from an icon archive using file explorer instead of 7-zip or winzip or what have you meant that it wouldn't prompt users to overwrite files and so either the file extraction would fail or it would overwrite files which overall probably isn't a huge deal initially however there are certain installers or certain other file processes where that could happen and if it doesn't ask you it could just be over writing things which could be a problem file deletion bugs period are unacceptable now a big issue that he raises here is that while theoretically the affected user base of the original 1880 no 9 update was fairly small due to the tier rollout that they do had they literally waited like three more days for the full rollout to go into effect head people like him and myself and people brought up I don't have any illusion that Microsoft has a clue who I am personally overall but had people not made enough noise about this issue with this update and they cancelled the rollout literally like a couple days before it would have just forced itself 100% on everybody there would have been millions and millions of people affected and this is now the second file deletion related bug with this particular update that they have missed now to Microsoft's credit and I kind of forgot to explain this in my last update video they did announce with the admitted admittance that the last update was bugged into leading users files and yadda-yadda they did announce that they are revamping the insider feedback hub and changing how user testers provide feedback and how they see it because clearly they missed all this all the feedbacks suggesting that the update was bugged and that's unacceptable and they I guess agree and are working to fix it however the fact that any of this needs to be done multiple years after the release of Windows 10 multiple years after they fired there laid off all their QA team and stopped testing things in-house in the first place is just becoming ridiculous in my opinion this is just ridiculous this is another bug that they're missing they're not testing it themselves they're relying on users to test it and a very flawed system of reporting for testing it and even the new system is based on users basically rating the M importance of their issue so that's supposedly if a user reports a file deletion bug it will seem more important than hey this random thing glitched out for a second however most users are like you know while testers are a more subgroup in the first place generally with these kind of feedback forms user she's just gonna always report their issue as of the utmost importance and it's still Microsoft's job to go through these and to find these issues in the first place so this is just getting ridiculous and again this is this is one where there are reports raining back from 1 to 3 months ago where it was already found and still being rolled out in this update now yes theoretically these kinds of initial update waves are only supposed to go to people who manually request them however that doesn't always work out and there were plenty of users both in the comments section of my video and multiple computers that I was utilizing myself and my grandmother's where updates were not manually requested and 18:09 was still forced itself upon those computers thankfully no files got deleted outside of my main rig where I did manually request the update but it's still getting a little bit ridiculous and at this point Windows users as Jason put it are at risk every time Microsoft fires out a Windows 10 update for something to go wrong for legacy computers to just get bricked or constant blue screens or just be unable to work anymore and those people are just crap out of luck for random file deletion bugs for drivers and programs to update because they're not doing enough in advance to prevent that because these feature updates are basically like service packs and that their entire new operating system versions and random drivers and stuff just break for no apparent reason things like that things that were not the case previously so at this point in time while I'd love to be like yeah go go go use Linux in yadda yadda I realize that's not a super realistic expectation or demand and I myself while I use Linux on all of my laptops and my side computers my primary work rig can't switch over to Linux do delay updates whenever possible don't manually request updates for Windows 10 don't try to seek them out if you're on a mission-critical machine and if you're on Windows 10 Pro by any chance which I don't necessarily recommend giving Microsoft more money in order to avoid their updates but if you happen to be on Windows there Windows 10 Pro you can actually just set it to defer updates altogether and kind of keep the delay going while I I have always been a person who thinks that security updates are important to install on your machine and you shouldn't avoid them it's getting stupid at this point and I just can't what I just can't suggest that people update their computers anymore which is a really weird position to be in I yeahall right I'm actually in the middle of recording a PC a really cool PC build project for my wife but we've got some more Windows 10 news that I'm not actually all that excited to share with you today and this camera was set up to do b-roll for the PC build so hopefully settings are right this is with my new Ursa mini pro 4.6 Kay have been working on loud learning rather so Jason Eve Angelo I hope that's how you say his name is a tech writer over at Forbes who I've been following and interacting a lot with with regards to Linux stuff and so naturally it comes up that there has been yet another file deletion bug discovered within the Windows 10 18:09 update now keep in mind 18:09 has apparently not actually started rolling back out to users yet and if you missed all of my videos there it rolled out and then there was an issue with it where it was deleting user library folders if you had moved them to another directory and left files in the previous one I outlined all of the issues that may have resulted in that affecting you in a previous video I'll have that linked in the description or the YouTube card icon or whatever and I was affected myself I had about three or four machines that all auto update it even though these are only supposed to be rolling out to insiders and those who manually chose the update I had a few rigs that auto updated and my grandmother's machine auto updated she didn't lose any files but her Microsoft Word installation and her printer drivers got totally borked like I was able eventually after like an hour fix her printer but her Microsoft Word installation is just all kinds of screwed but it was affecting a lot of people and while a lot of people thought I was just being a conspiracy theorist there were a lot of people also in the comments echoing that it was affecting them as well well while insiders were more thoroughly testing the 18:09 bug or 18:09 update same thing I guess as it's supposed to be fixed now and rolling back out they have discovered another file deletion bug that results from their file extracting during the update process we're extracting from an icon archive using file explorer instead of 7-zip or winzip or what have you meant that it wouldn't prompt users to overwrite files and so either the file extraction would fail or it would overwrite files which overall probably isn't a huge deal initially however there are certain installers or certain other file processes where that could happen and if it doesn't ask you it could just be over writing things which could be a problem file deletion bugs period are unacceptable now a big issue that he raises here is that while theoretically the affected user base of the original 1880 no 9 update was fairly small due to the tier rollout that they do had they literally waited like three more days for the full rollout to go into effect head people like him and myself and people brought up I don't have any illusion that Microsoft has a clue who I am personally overall but had people not made enough noise about this issue with this update and they cancelled the rollout literally like a couple days before it would have just forced itself 100% on everybody there would have been millions and millions of people affected and this is now the second file deletion related bug with this particular update that they have missed now to Microsoft's credit and I kind of forgot to explain this in my last update video they did announce with the admitted admittance that the last update was bugged into leading users files and yadda-yadda they did announce that they are revamping the insider feedback hub and changing how user testers provide feedback and how they see it because clearly they missed all this all the feedbacks suggesting that the update was bugged and that's unacceptable and they I guess agree and are working to fix it however the fact that any of this needs to be done multiple years after the release of Windows 10 multiple years after they fired there laid off all their QA team and stopped testing things in-house in the first place is just becoming ridiculous in my opinion this is just ridiculous this is another bug that they're missing they're not testing it themselves they're relying on users to test it and a very flawed system of reporting for testing it and even the new system is based on users basically rating the M importance of their issue so that's supposedly if a user reports a file deletion bug it will seem more important than hey this random thing glitched out for a second however most users are like you know while testers are a more subgroup in the first place generally with these kind of feedback forms user she's just gonna always report their issue as of the utmost importance and it's still Microsoft's job to go through these and to find these issues in the first place so this is just getting ridiculous and again this is this is one where there are reports raining back from 1 to 3 months ago where it was already found and still being rolled out in this update now yes theoretically these kinds of initial update waves are only supposed to go to people who manually request them however that doesn't always work out and there were plenty of users both in the comments section of my video and multiple computers that I was utilizing myself and my grandmother's where updates were not manually requested and 18:09 was still forced itself upon those computers thankfully no files got deleted outside of my main rig where I did manually request the update but it's still getting a little bit ridiculous and at this point Windows users as Jason put it are at risk every time Microsoft fires out a Windows 10 update for something to go wrong for legacy computers to just get bricked or constant blue screens or just be unable to work anymore and those people are just crap out of luck for random file deletion bugs for drivers and programs to update because they're not doing enough in advance to prevent that because these feature updates are basically like service packs and that their entire new operating system versions and random drivers and stuff just break for no apparent reason things like that things that were not the case previously so at this point in time while I'd love to be like yeah go go go use Linux in yadda yadda I realize that's not a super realistic expectation or demand and I myself while I use Linux on all of my laptops and my side computers my primary work rig can't switch over to Linux do delay updates whenever possible don't manually request updates for Windows 10 don't try to seek them out if you're on a mission-critical machine and if you're on Windows 10 Pro by any chance which I don't necessarily recommend giving Microsoft more money in order to avoid their updates but if you happen to be on Windows there Windows 10 Pro you can actually just set it to defer updates altogether and kind of keep the delay going while I I have always been a person who thinks that security updates are important to install on your machine and you shouldn't avoid them it's getting stupid at this point and I just can't what I just can't suggest that people update their computers anymore which is a really weird position to be in I yeah\n"