The Camera Comparison: iPhone 10 vs Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus
We recently had the opportunity to test and compare the camera capabilities of the iPhone 10 and the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus. In this article, we'll delve into our findings and explore the strengths and weaknesses of each device's camera system.
**Exposure and Detail in Dark Areas**
One of the most noticeable differences between the two devices is their handling of exposure in dark areas. The Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus exposed brighter images, but unfortunately, it also crushed the detail in dark areas like hair. On the other hand, the iPhone 10 struggled to expose properly, resulting in blown-out clouds and a loss of detail.
We noticed that manually choosing the F 2.4 aperture mode on the Samsung improved exposure, but even then, we experienced issues with contrast and sharpness. We also tried switching to F 1.5 mode, which resulted in similar problems, including some loss of detail and sharpness. Adjusting the exposure compensation setting helped, but we still noticed blown-out clouds.
It's worth noting that DR (Dynamic Range) doesn't work in Pro mode on the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus, so it's best to avoid using this feature when taking photos against a bright background.
**Wide Angle Lenses**
Using wide-angle lenses, we observed that both devices struggled with contrast and saturation. However, the iPhone 10 had more contrast, which made its images appear more true to life. The Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus, on the other hand, looked more natural but lacked detail in the shadows.
When switching to portrait mode, we noticed that the iPhone 10's lens was so wide that it distorted the subject's body, making their head look small. In contrast, the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus blurs the background and the foreground, creating a professional camera effect at a fast aperture.
**Selfie Mode**
Using selfie mode, we saw that the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus has a wider lens than the iPhone 10, which resulted in an unnatural perspective. The device's lens also seemed to distort the subject's body, making their head appear smaller than usual.
The iPhone 10's selfie mode, on the other hand, blurs the foreground and background, creating a more flattering effect. However, we noticed that it struggled to maintain consistent blur amounts near the ear. The Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus had a similar issue with maintaining highlight details outside of the frame.
**Portrait Mode**
In portrait mode, we observed that both devices have strong blur effects, but they differ in terms of consistency and quality. The iPhone 10's blur effect was less consistent, while the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus produced a more even and natural-looking effect.
However, when using Portrait + Light mode on the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus, it struggled to keep the blur amount consistent near the ear. In contrast, the iPhone 10's portrait mode seemed to perform better in this regard.
**Low-Light Photography**
For low-light photography, we started with F 2.4 aperture mode on the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus and noticed that it performed better than expected. However, when switching to F 1.5 mode, the image suffered from significant noise and loss of detail.
In contrast, the iPhone 10's F 1.5 mode reduced noise but lost detail as well. We also noticed that the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus dropped its shutter speed to an extremely low 1/8 of a second in both modes, which would undoubtedly cause motion blur if the subject moved at all.
**Shutter Speed and ISO**
We manually raised the shutter speed on the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus to one thirtieth of a second to help with this issue but it also forced the ISO setting into Manual mode, which was annoying. In contrast, the iPhone 10's slower shutter speed resulted in brighter images but also increased noise.
**Flash Photography**
When using flash photography, we saw that the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus had more detail than the iPhone 10, but both devices struggled with the distracting bright effect of the flash. However, when switching to telephoto lenses, the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus's image was over-sharpened due to the bright flash effect.
In contrast, the iPhone 10's image looked more pleasant and balanced despite the loss in detail.
**Conclusion**
Ultimately, both devices have extremely good cameras with their own strengths and weaknesses. The iPhone 10 excels in portrait mode and low-light photography, while the Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus performs better in landscape shots and offers a wider range of camera modes.
However, it's essential to note that each device has its unique quirks and limitations. The Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus struggles with exposure in dark areas, while the iPhone 10 has inconsistent blur amounts near the ear.
Whether you're a photographer or an avid smartphone user, we recommend carefully considering your specific needs and preferences before making a purchase decision.