GoodNotes vs Notability - Best iPad Notes App For Apple Pencil Users
**The Best Handwriting-Driven Notes Apps for iPad: A Comprehensive Comparison**
---
**Introduction**
Today’s video is brought to you by *Paper-like*, an innovative accessory that enhances drawing and writing on your iPad, making it feel more like paper. Whether you're a student, a professional, or someone who enjoys taking notes on the go, this video dives deep into the world of handwriting-driven note-taking apps for iPad. Specifically, we’re comparing two highly-regarded apps: *GoodNotes* and *Notability*.
The goal is to help you determine which app suits your workflow best. We’ll explore features like design, handwriting quality, tools, typing capabilities, search functions, and more. Additionally, we’ll touch on cross-platform compatibility, alternatives, and the unique aspects that set these apps apart.
---
**Why These Apps?**
There are countless note-taking apps available for Apple users, but not all of them fully leverage the iPad’s unique capabilities, especially when it comes to handwriting and Apple Pencil support. While some apps prioritize typing as the primary input method, others are designed specifically with handwriting in mind.
For this comparison, we chose *GoodNotes* and *Notability* because they are both highly-rated and consistently referenced as the top options for iPad users who prefer handwriting-driven note-taking. These apps offer a wide variety of features, including support for handwritten text, diagrams, sketches, typed text, audio recordings, web clips, PDFs, and more. Additionally, a powerful search function is essential for organizing notes effectively.
---
**Design & Interface**
When it comes to design and interface, *Notability* stands out with its clean, modern approach that embraces the digital canvas. In contrast, *GoodNotes* aims to replicate the look and feel of a physical notebook, which may appeal to those who prefer a more traditional paper-like experience.
One significant difference is how these apps handle scrolling versus adding new sheets. *Notability* offers infinite scrolling within a note, giving you unlimited space to write without interruption. On the other hand, *GoodNotes* requires users to add new sheets when they run out of room. While this can be functional, it may slow down your workflow if you prefer writing horizontally, as the app defaults to vertical orientation for new sheets.
---
**Handwriting Experience**
The feel and realism of digital ink are crucial factors for anyone who takes handwritten notes. Both apps perform similarly in terms of handwriting quality, but *GoodNotes* edges out *Notability* with slightly better-looking and feeling digital ink. However, the difference is subtle, and it’s something you’d notice only after extended use.
A major drawback for *GoodNotes* is its inability to convert handwritten text to typed text accurately. During testing, even simple words were converted into garbled gibberish, which is a significant limitation for those who rely on this feature. In contrast, *Notability* excels in this area, converting both text and bullet points with ease.
---
**Main Tools & Features**
Both apps offer a variety of pen options and tools for customization. *Notability* provides two pen types: one with an even stroke and another that’s more tapered. *GoodNotes*, on the other hand, offers three pen options—a fountain pen, ball pen, or brush pen—along with multiple sizes and colors.
For highlighting, *GoodNotes* takes the lead by placing highlights behind written text, preventing them from obscuring your notes. This feature makes it easier to read highlighted sections compared to *Notability*, where highlights sit on top of text.
Erasing is another area where these apps differ significantly. *Notability*’s eraser tool is quick, smart, and precise, requiring only a touch to erase entire lines. In contrast, *GoodNotes* forces users to manually erase every pixel, which can be time-consuming despite offering three eraser sizes.
Both apps allow you to draw perfect shapes, but *GoodNotes* has a dedicated button for this purpose, making it more convenient than *Notability*, which only supports perfect circles and lines.
---
**Typing & Additional Features**
While both apps are primarily handwriting-driven, *Notability* offers superior typing features compared to *GoodNotes*. Its typing capabilities are more powerful, with better-looking text and support for outlines and checklists. This makes *Notability* the better choice for users who occasionally need to type within their notes.
Search functionality is another critical feature for note-taking apps. Unfortunately, *GoodNotes* struggles with searching handwritten texts, often returning no results when attempting to index handwriting. On the other hand, *Notability* excels in this area, delivering accurate and useful search results despite not being able to read 100% of the text.
Audio recording is a standout feature in *Notability*. The app allows you to record audio while taking notes, with playback options like speed adjustment and ten-second rewind. It even offers an "Instant Replay" feature that animates your notes as they were written during playback—a feature that’s currently on *GoodNotes*’s roadmap.
---
**Unique Features & Alternatives**
Beyond the basics, *Notability* offers several unique features that set it apart from *GoodNotes*. One of the most notable is its multi-document view, which provides a split-screen dual note interface. This allows users to multitask by referring to one note while creating or editing another. Additionally, *Notability* supports themes, including a dark mode, and offers thoughtful little features like importing PDFs by selecting specific pages rather than the entire document.
While *GoodNotes* doesn’t have a Mac app, it does offer unique features like custom paper templates and notebook cover designs. However, these advanced options are likely not essential for most users.
For those exploring alternatives, *Wink* is worth mentioning for its sleek design, though it lacks features like OCR and handwriting search. *NoShell 2* is another contender with excellent pen tools, but it’s more of a competitor to Apple Notes due to its focus on typing.
---
**Cross-Platform Use & Alternatives**
While both apps are excellent, they have their limitations when it comes to cross-platform use. *GoodNotes* currently only offers iOS support, while *Notability* is also available on the Mac App Store for an additional $9.99. This makes *Notability* a more versatile choice for users who want seamless integration across devices.
For those looking for alternatives, *Paper by WeTransfer* is not directly comparable as it’s primarily designed for sketching rather than note-taking.
---
**Conclusion**
After testing both apps extensively and weighing their features, the verdict is clear: *Notability* comes out on top. While *GoodNotes* has its strengths, particularly in handwriting and digital ink, *Notability*’s design, user interface, additional features, and overall functionality make it the superior choice for the host.
However, if you’re someone who prefers a more traditional paper-like experience and doesn’t mind sacrificing some of the advanced features offered by *Notability*, *GoodNotes* could still be worth considering. Ultimately, the best app for you depends on your personal preferences and workflow needs.
---
**Final Thoughts & Community Interaction**
Before wrapping up, the host encourages viewers to engage with the video by leaving comments and suggestions. He also hints at future content, including a deep dive into Apple Notes and updates on upcoming features like multitasking videos and vlogs.
The video concludes with a promotional mention of *Paper-like*, an accessory that enhances the feel of writing on your iPad, especially when used with apps like *Notability* or Procreate. Those interested in purchasing can find more information in the description below.
Thank you for watching, and we’ll see you in the next video!