How to Properly Mulch Around a Tree _ This Old House

**The Silent Killer: Understanding the Dangers of Mulch Volcanoes and Proper Tree Care**

Trees are some of the most valuable elements in our landscapes, providing beauty, shade, and life-sustaining benefits. However, improper tree care practices can lead to severe damage or even death for these majestic plants. One such issue is the "mulch volcano," a common landscaping practice that has detrimental effects on trees.

In this article, we will explore the dangers of mulch volcanoes, the importance of proper root flare exposure, and effective tree care techniques based on a detailed transcription from a video.

---

### The Problem with Mulch Volcanoes

The video begins by highlighting the issue of "mulch volcanoes," a term used to describe excessive piles of mulch around the base of trees. Landscape professionals often pile mulch year after year, creating a volcano-like structure around the tree trunk. While mulch is beneficial in many ways, this practice can be devastating for trees.

The speaker explains that mulch volcanoes suffocate the root mass. Tree roots require oxygen to survive, and by covering them with excessive mulch, landscapers are essentially suffocating the roots. This lack of oxygen leads to bark falling off, which is a clear sign of stress and potential death for the tree. The speaker emphasizes that this tree is "a goner" unless drastic measures are taken.

---

### Excavation Reveals Hidden Problems

To demonstrate the extent of the damage, the speaker decides to excavate the affected tree. As they remove the mulch, several issues become apparent:

1. **Drip Irrigation Placement**: The video shows that the drip irrigation system is installed directly on top of the root ball. This placement can further exacerbate the problem by directing water away from the roots and into the mulch layer, which can trap moisture and lead to root rot.

2. **Secondary Root Systems**: The excavation reveals an extensive network of secondary roots growing upward into the mulch. These roots are trying to escape the suffocating environment below but are instead exposed to harsh conditions such as sunburn and frost damage. Over time, these roots can circle around the trunk, leading to a condition known as "girdling," which can strangle the tree and lead to its death.

---

### Correcting the Issues

The speaker then demonstrates how to correct these problems:

1. **Removing Mulch**: The first step is to remove all the mulch from around the base of the tree. This allows the roots to breathe freely and prevents further damage to the bark.

2. **Exposing Root Flares**: After removing the mulch, the root flare (the point where the trunk meets the roots) becomes visible. The speaker emphasizes that this is a critical step because it ensures proper air circulation and allows the tree to function as nature intended.

3. **Trimming Secondary Roots**: Any secondary roots growing upward are trimmed to prevent future girdling. This process may seem drastic, but it is necessary for the long-term health of the tree.

4. **Using Air Tools for Soil Removal**: The speaker uses an air compressor to blast soil off the tree base. This method is effective because it removes debris without damaging the roots or the trunk.

---

### Replanting and Proper Mulching

Once the root system has been exposed and cleaned, the next step is to replant the tree correctly:

1. **Adding Topsoil**: A thin layer of topsoil is added to fill in any voids around the base of the tree. It’s important not to cover the primary root flare during this process.

2. **Mulching Correctly**: The final step is mulching, but this time it's done properly. Instead of creating a "volcano," the speaker spreads the mulch evenly and keeps it shallow (no more than two inches deep). This approach ensures that the root flare remains exposed while providing benefits such as weed control, moisture retention, and protection from extreme temperatures.

---

### Conclusion

The video serves as a stark reminder of the importance of proper tree care. Mulch volcanoes may seem harmless at first glance, but they can lead to severe damage or even death for trees. By exposing root flares, avoiding excessive mulching, and ensuring proper irrigation placement, we can help our trees thrive.

In summary, always remember:

- Avoid piling mulch against the trunk.

- Keep root flares exposed to ensure healthy root development.

- Monitor for secondary roots that may indicate stress or damage.

- Use drip irrigation systems wisely, avoiding direct contact with the root ball.

By following these steps, we can protect our trees and enjoy their beauty and benefits for years to come.

"WEBVTTKind: captionsLanguage: enshow me the roof flare on this tree right here i don't see a root flare mat it looks like a telephone pole going in the ground this is the classic mulch volcano what the landscapers do is keep on piling mulch year after year after year causing this mulch volcano but it's just mulch how can it hurt the tree it's suffocating the root mass the roots actually breathe by putting all this mulch on top of it it suffocates it causing the bark to fall off this tree's a goner it's gonna have to be removed you're kidding me i'm going to excavate this and show you what the problem is great see what's going on oh i see drip irrigation on top of the root ball i never like to see it on top of the root ball i'd rather see it out over here to get the fibrous root mass breaking out in the direction that we want it right we want those roots growing out not up into the ball correct now look at all these secondary root systems that's really something isn't it right yeah and that secondary root system isn't good it indicates that the primary root system is suffocated down below and these roots have come up and grown into the mulch looking for oxygen that's right roger this secondary root system when it comes up into the mulch volcano it's the first to get cooked by the sun in the summertime it's also the first to get burnt by the frost in the winter time additionally these roots will circle around the main stem compacting this area further girdling the tree in the future a girdling root will actually dig into the tree and can cause it to die over time there any here we can save i'll show you this one over here looks pretty good a little cherry it's got nice full form crown on it i don't see any of the bark falling off i'd start out by removing all this mulch let's get to it well that's about all we'll do with the hand tools roger the rest of it we'll take out with a power tool i have a compressor here that i'm going to fire up then compress the air down this lines of the tool which we're going to use to blast mountain soil off the tree base the air wand removes all the soil but it doesn't damage the roots or the trees uh you can actually see the wire basket the remnants of it left here from the original planting well matt now we can really see that root flare right there yeah and all these secondary roots that are coming up right here this one's crossing right over the flare that would be a problem in the future wouldn't it we're going to cut all these roots off that are going up so anything coming up gets cut right okay okay we got just a few more to go yeah it's looking good now now with the secondary root system gone you can really see that primary flare and how it sits right at ground level all right we just want to add a little bit of topsoil to fill in some of the voids around the tree remember we do not want to cover the primary root flare now we're ready for mulch but no more volcanoes i don't like to just dump the whole wheelbarrow on there i like to put it on by hand so we can gauge the depth and make sure we don't have much more than two inches now the mulch is important for a couple of reasons it keeps the grass from growing up next to the tree it holds moisture in the soil and it also keeps weeds from popping up and most importantly we're not covering up the root flair the way that nature intended it to beshow me the roof flare on this tree right here i don't see a root flare mat it looks like a telephone pole going in the ground this is the classic mulch volcano what the landscapers do is keep on piling mulch year after year after year causing this mulch volcano but it's just mulch how can it hurt the tree it's suffocating the root mass the roots actually breathe by putting all this mulch on top of it it suffocates it causing the bark to fall off this tree's a goner it's gonna have to be removed you're kidding me i'm going to excavate this and show you what the problem is great see what's going on oh i see drip irrigation on top of the root ball i never like to see it on top of the root ball i'd rather see it out over here to get the fibrous root mass breaking out in the direction that we want it right we want those roots growing out not up into the ball correct now look at all these secondary root systems that's really something isn't it right yeah and that secondary root system isn't good it indicates that the primary root system is suffocated down below and these roots have come up and grown into the mulch looking for oxygen that's right roger this secondary root system when it comes up into the mulch volcano it's the first to get cooked by the sun in the summertime it's also the first to get burnt by the frost in the winter time additionally these roots will circle around the main stem compacting this area further girdling the tree in the future a girdling root will actually dig into the tree and can cause it to die over time there any here we can save i'll show you this one over here looks pretty good a little cherry it's got nice full form crown on it i don't see any of the bark falling off i'd start out by removing all this mulch let's get to it well that's about all we'll do with the hand tools roger the rest of it we'll take out with a power tool i have a compressor here that i'm going to fire up then compress the air down this lines of the tool which we're going to use to blast mountain soil off the tree base the air wand removes all the soil but it doesn't damage the roots or the trees uh you can actually see the wire basket the remnants of it left here from the original planting well matt now we can really see that root flare right there yeah and all these secondary roots that are coming up right here this one's crossing right over the flare that would be a problem in the future wouldn't it we're going to cut all these roots off that are going up so anything coming up gets cut right okay okay we got just a few more to go yeah it's looking good now now with the secondary root system gone you can really see that primary flare and how it sits right at ground level all right we just want to add a little bit of topsoil to fill in some of the voids around the tree remember we do not want to cover the primary root flare now we're ready for mulch but no more volcanoes i don't like to just dump the whole wheelbarrow on there i like to put it on by hand so we can gauge the depth and make sure we don't have much more than two inches now the mulch is important for a couple of reasons it keeps the grass from growing up next to the tree it holds moisture in the soil and it also keeps weeds from popping up and most importantly we're not covering up the root flair the way that nature intended it to be\n"