Jay from Jay's Two Cents recently shared his experience with one of his CPUs and noticed something similar with another CPU. He believes that this is definitely a known issue, and they've tried everything from reinstalling Windows to reinstalling GTA drivers, XMP changes, and overclocking. However, the issue persists.
He mentioned that dropping XMP when turning off the profile and going down to 2133 MHz seems to alleviate some of the problem but still leaves it present. They haven't fully figured out the cause yet, but benchmarks show that the two affected CPUs have a slight performance anomaly compared to other processors in similar games. Jay suspects that there might be some sort of GTA issue when testing with a iCAN fig, and anyone who's got thoughts on this post should share their opinions in the comments below.
The charts showing the average FPS of 101 for the I5 2500k with overclocking, pushing up to 124 FPS average, compare favorably to the i72600k. However, there's not a significant advantage seen from the extra threads and cores offered by these processors. The frequency seems to provide the biggest impact to performance, at least in most games.
In contrast, the I5 3570k operates about 11 FPS faster than the stock I5 2500k. Other I5s like the 6600 and 7600k seem to have some issues but are still able to achieve averages of around 123-129 FPS. Jay and his team have done extensive research on these processors, trying everything from Windows reinstallations to completely fresh platforms, drivers, CPU changes, XMP changes, overclocking, and even checking the memory bus or memory controller speed.
However, they haven't been able to figure out what's causing the issues with those two specific CPUs. The 2500k has held up relatively well over the past five years but is now starting to show its age in a few specific games, particularly Watch Dogs 2. They're seeing sizable differences between modern CPUs on this particular title, and multicore does seem to matter more for that game.
In addition, Jay pointed out that they've seen big gains from overclocking in many games, especially since the 2500k was so easy to overclock. If you have one of these processors, it might be worth giving it a good cooler, like an AIo, and pushing it up to 4.5 GHz for the remainder of its life.
Blender and rendering tasks are particularly abusive to the I5 2500K, with modern CPUs outpacing it nearly two-fold. This suggests that it's now a good time to upgrade from this processor. Modern GPUs might get bottlenecked by the I5 2500K, especially if you're aiming for anything above the 1060 and 480 class, such as the 1070 and 1080, or whatever Vega may bring.
Normally, Jay wouldn't recommend waiting for CPU upgrades unless there's something specific you want. A lot of the time is spent waiting for component upgrades in general because there's always something new on the horizon, but Zen is close enough to wait now that it should be launching next month.
If a new Intel CPU were coming out next month, Jay might suggest not waiting just because we know their gains are pretty small on average generally. However, if you need a system now, it's worth buying. Zen is a big deal for AMD, as they haven't released anything major in several years since this CPU came out.
In conclusion, the I5 2500K has held up well but is starting to show its age. It might be time to upgrade, especially if you're planning on using it with modern GPUs. The 7600k or 6600k might be worth looking into, as they offer similar performance at a potentially lower price point. Alternatively, an i9-4690K could also be considered if one can find it for cheap.
That's all Jay has to say about the I5 2500K for now. If you want to see more results or further analysis, check out the link in the description below, where there are additional benchmarks and some further discussion on these processors. As always, subscribe for more content, and support Jay through his Patreon link for exclusive rewards.
For those interested in watching the full video, it's available on YouTube, along with other videos from Jay's channel, which can be found in the description below.