Tiff VS Jason in McLaren MP4-12C vs Ferrari 458 Italia the FULL challenge _ Fifth Gear Classic

The Prowess of Porsche: A Test Drive Experience with the 911 GT3 Cup

As we stepped out of our car and onto the track, it was clear that this was going to be a day like no other. The Porsche 911 GT3 Cup, with its sleek design and powerful engine, was ready to put its mettle to the test against one of the most iconic supercars on the market - the McLaren 720S.

The Ferrari 458 Italia was our first subject for testing, and we couldn't wait to see how it would perform. With its 6.0-liter V8 twin-turbo engine producing 600 horsepower, this car is a force to be reckoned with. Weighing in at just 150 kilograms, it's a lean and mean fighting machine that's designed to deliver exceptional performance.

As we climbed into the driver's seat of the Ferrari, we were immediately struck by its comfort and refinement. The interior was trimmed in luxurious leather and Alcantara, with precise stitching and a subtle aroma of Italian craftsmanship. But as soon as we started driving, it became clear that this car is all about speed - and lots of it.

With a top speed of 205 mph, the Ferrari can accelerate from 0-60 mph in just 2.9 seconds, making it one of the quickest production cars on the market. But what really sets it apart is its ability to deliver an incredible sense of driving excitement. Whether we were pushing hard through the corners or cruising down the straight, this car seemed to come alive under our hands.

Of course, with great power comes great responsibility - and the Ferrari's engineers have clearly worked hard to ensure that this machine is both fun and safe. The traction control system is incredibly effective, allowing us to drive aggressively without worrying about losing control of the car.

But as we made our way back to the pits, it was clear that the real star of the show was not just the Ferrari - but also our trusty sidekick, Tim. With his years of experience and natural driving talent, he was able to coax out of this car a level of performance and excitement that was truly remarkable.

In contrast, the McLaren 720S presented a very different challenge. Weighing in at a whopping $173,000, this car is undoubtedly one of the most expensive supercars on the market - but it's also an engineering tour-de-force that's designed to deliver exceptional handling and performance.

As we climbed into the driver's seat of the McLaren, we were immediately struck by its sheer size and presence. This car is a behemoth of the automotive world, with a 4.0-liter twin-turbo V8 engine producing 710 horsepower. And yet, despite its massive weight - a staggering 1,600 kilograms - it feels eerily light on its feet.

The handling of this car is truly remarkable, with exceptional balance and agility that allows us to push hard through the corners without worrying about losing control. But as we made our way around the track, it became clear that there's one major problem: the gearbox.

While the engine and suspension are both superbly engineered, the transmission feels decidedly clunky - a harsh shift that disrupts the flow of driving experience. And in terms of fun factor? Sorry, mate - this car just can't compete with the Ferrari when it comes to delivering an emotional connection between driver and machine.

In the end, our test drive experience was clear: while the McLaren 720S is undoubtedly one of the most impressive engineering feats on the market, it falls short when it comes to sheer driving excitement. The Ferrari, on the other hand, is a masterclass in performance and design - but with a critical caveat that its handling can be nervously unpredictable at times.

As we climbed out of the Ferrari's cockpit and back into our own car, we couldn't help but feel a little disappointed by the McLaren's performance. Despite its impressive specs and engineering credentials, it just didn't quite deliver on the fun factor - and when it comes to that critical element of driving excitement, there can only be one winner.

And so, with a clear winner in mind, we settled back into our car, ready to put our thoughts into words. The Ferrari 458 Italia is undoubtedly one of the most iconic and desirable supercars on the market - but beneath its sleek design and powerful engine lies a driving experience that's both thrilling and nuanced.

So what did we learn from this test drive experience? For starters, it's clear that while raw performance is undeniably important, there's also something special about creating an emotional connection between driver and machine. The Ferrari 458 Italia nails this aspect with its exceptional handling and responsiveness - but at a cost to fun factor.

And what of the McLaren 720S? While its engineering credentials are undoubtedly impressive, it falls short when it comes to delivering that all-important driving excitement. Despite its massive performance figures, it feels like a car that's always on edge - never quite as engaged or responsive as we'd hoped.

So there you have it - our verdict on this epic test drive experience. The Ferrari 458 Italia is undoubtedly one of the most thrilling supercars on the market - but with a critical caveat about its handling. The McLaren 720S, meanwhile? Well, while it's undeniably an engineering marvel, it falls short in the all-important department that really matters: driving excitement.

As we climbed back into our car and headed off into the sunset, one thing was clear: both of these supercars are winners - but only when it comes to performance credentials. When it comes to creating a truly unforgettable driving experience? The Ferrari takes the cake.

"WEBVTTKind: captionsLanguage: enand now it's time wait for it to find out about the car we've all been dying to hear about the mclaren mp4 12c what a car what a car do you mind i'm just taking it in don't ruin it don't know just don't speak oh i've got it a brand new 205 mile an hour british supercar built in surrey underneath here is a little sensor oh yeah yeah that's nice and that's to save weight by the people who run jetson button and lewis hamilton in formula one let's have a look where the meat and veggies it's in here somewhere to open there we go yeah the point was they couldn't find an engine small enough or light enough which is why they made their own it's uh it's tiny isn't it i mean it's 3.8 v8 twin turbo weighs 150 kilos it's not produces six hundred meters six hundred horsepower it's one hundred and sixty eight thousand five hundred pounds worth of exquisite engineering i'll get in there now are you comfy ah i'm not sure i am actually oh that's nice look how far i can adjust that you happy now hold on did you know that grip was moulded on lewis's grip i like it i like it no buttons on the string look at this indicator store look lovely hold on i think that's jensen's bottom don't stop no i do you've got louis griffin the mclaren needs to be measured against the best the 173 thousand pound ferrari 458 italia serious cars require serious testing so we'll both drive them i'll test how much fun you can add while i'm here to see which can set the fastest possible laptop we'll start with the benchmark ferrari's ability to play on my face already the confidence is unbelievable it's the best thing in the world isn't this car oh breathe but now hold it this has been a smile trope the mclaren's got to do so much to beat this for sheer driving ecstasy next it's my turn in the 458 to see what it's like when you just want to go fast it's just amazing electric experience oh that looks fast this is a flat out 140 mile an hour corner and we're sideways and it's not it's not an effort i love this car i love it it's my favorite ever carp so far yeah so far and now time to see how the mclaren compares by first testing how much fun it is and a very different feel to it immediately oh my god here he comes first time around the mclaren i can't wait come on well actually let's step back a bit turning in with the big oversteer he doesn't look comfy in it i'm not having so much fun well well whoa edgy yeah you look a bit twitchy it's nothing like as consistently i've got to learn to drive this more than i did the ferrari that was instantly in my hands come on tim you know what the kids want they want a big tiff drift give me a chance the trouble was i was trying to make the mclaren do exactly what it's programmed not to do flick it go go now oh my god we're off efo tiffo tfo tip what's going on man what's going on even with the traction control turned off the car reduced the torque just when i needed it to hold the drift then as the rear tires began to grip and i was starting to steer out of the slide the car tried to save itself with brake steer all of which combine to create the massive over correction that turned us into a high-speed lawn mower you're not happy with it it's not just basically it's not set up the final test was my fast luck where the mclaren was a tenth of a second slower than that ferrari but how did it feel did he like it did he like it and i don't like it i'm the same as if i've got less confidence than this i don't i'm not feeling the car as much tell me why i don't like it it's his ear there's a disconnection between me i don't know when the last time i spun a car was quite some time ago i'm not in tune with the car you know to get the best out of it you've probably got to drive it the way mclaren want you to and the way it's been programmed and now i'm not programmed that way it stops quicker and better than the ferrari it's very very nervous on the brakes it squirms around downshift no it won't downshift when i want to but the big thing is it's nowhere near as much fun and engaging to thrive exciting i'm sorry i'm sorry as a friend i mean that's just honesty generally genuinely disappointed that was a good day wasn't it it was what a day we turned up and fell in love with this black stealth mclaren with its luxurious refined interior absolutely and you know in terms of a piece of engineering it is a work of art the detail the finish the fit is second to none but there's a butt and it's a very very big butt the engine isn't as good agreed the gearbox isn't as good agreed the handling isn't as good very much agreed you see on paper this car is better than the ferrari but there's one thing which you don't get on paper and that's how it makes you feel the tingle the special feeling you get inside when you're driving it and that knocks spots off that there can only be one winner and it's a clear winner the ferrari youand now it's time wait for it to find out about the car we've all been dying to hear about the mclaren mp4 12c what a car what a car do you mind i'm just taking it in don't ruin it don't know just don't speak oh i've got it a brand new 205 mile an hour british supercar built in surrey underneath here is a little sensor oh yeah yeah that's nice and that's to save weight by the people who run jetson button and lewis hamilton in formula one let's have a look where the meat and veggies it's in here somewhere to open there we go yeah the point was they couldn't find an engine small enough or light enough which is why they made their own it's uh it's tiny isn't it i mean it's 3.8 v8 twin turbo weighs 150 kilos it's not produces six hundred meters six hundred horsepower it's one hundred and sixty eight thousand five hundred pounds worth of exquisite engineering i'll get in there now are you comfy ah i'm not sure i am actually oh that's nice look how far i can adjust that you happy now hold on did you know that grip was moulded on lewis's grip i like it i like it no buttons on the string look at this indicator store look lovely hold on i think that's jensen's bottom don't stop no i do you've got louis griffin the mclaren needs to be measured against the best the 173 thousand pound ferrari 458 italia serious cars require serious testing so we'll both drive them i'll test how much fun you can add while i'm here to see which can set the fastest possible laptop we'll start with the benchmark ferrari's ability to play on my face already the confidence is unbelievable it's the best thing in the world isn't this car oh breathe but now hold it this has been a smile trope the mclaren's got to do so much to beat this for sheer driving ecstasy next it's my turn in the 458 to see what it's like when you just want to go fast it's just amazing electric experience oh that looks fast this is a flat out 140 mile an hour corner and we're sideways and it's not it's not an effort i love this car i love it it's my favorite ever carp so far yeah so far and now time to see how the mclaren compares by first testing how much fun it is and a very different feel to it immediately oh my god here he comes first time around the mclaren i can't wait come on well actually let's step back a bit turning in with the big oversteer he doesn't look comfy in it i'm not having so much fun well well whoa edgy yeah you look a bit twitchy it's nothing like as consistently i've got to learn to drive this more than i did the ferrari that was instantly in my hands come on tim you know what the kids want they want a big tiff drift give me a chance the trouble was i was trying to make the mclaren do exactly what it's programmed not to do flick it go go now oh my god we're off efo tiffo tfo tip what's going on man what's going on even with the traction control turned off the car reduced the torque just when i needed it to hold the drift then as the rear tires began to grip and i was starting to steer out of the slide the car tried to save itself with brake steer all of which combine to create the massive over correction that turned us into a high-speed lawn mower you're not happy with it it's not just basically it's not set up the final test was my fast luck where the mclaren was a tenth of a second slower than that ferrari but how did it feel did he like it did he like it and i don't like it i'm the same as if i've got less confidence than this i don't i'm not feeling the car as much tell me why i don't like it it's his ear there's a disconnection between me i don't know when the last time i spun a car was quite some time ago i'm not in tune with the car you know to get the best out of it you've probably got to drive it the way mclaren want you to and the way it's been programmed and now i'm not programmed that way it stops quicker and better than the ferrari it's very very nervous on the brakes it squirms around downshift no it won't downshift when i want to but the big thing is it's nowhere near as much fun and engaging to thrive exciting i'm sorry i'm sorry as a friend i mean that's just honesty generally genuinely disappointed that was a good day wasn't it it was what a day we turned up and fell in love with this black stealth mclaren with its luxurious refined interior absolutely and you know in terms of a piece of engineering it is a work of art the detail the finish the fit is second to none but there's a butt and it's a very very big butt the engine isn't as good agreed the gearbox isn't as good agreed the handling isn't as good very much agreed you see on paper this car is better than the ferrari but there's one thing which you don't get on paper and that's how it makes you feel the tingle the special feeling you get inside when you're driving it and that knocks spots off that there can only be one winner and it's a clear winner the ferrari you\n"